The Genius Cripple trope is pronounced in representations of disability in popular media and is generally grounded in the idea of a mind-body dichotomy. The notion of the mind-body dichotomy assumes that the mind and body are distinct from one another. This dichotomy is traced back to the philosopher Descartes, who suggested a distinction between the two when he allied consciousness with the mind rather than with the body overall, and so this is often referred to as a Cartesian Dichotomy (referring to Descartes). The more we learn about the body, the more we see that ideas of consciousness are not limited entirely to the head or the mind, but they are distributed and dependent on impulses and chemicals produced throughout the body.
The trope of “The Genius Cripple” is probably most prominent in the representation of Charles Xavier from the X-Men, a figure who is both a wheelchair user as well as a telepath and genius. This trope is inspired by the belief amongst able-bodied people that one “weakness” in the body creates a strength—something portrayed frequently in statements like, “When someone becomes blind, their other senses become stronger.” Charles Xavier represents the assumption that wheelchair users are a representation of a bodily “flaw” and Xavier is therefore portrayed as having greater mental strengths. Although the creators are not trying to say that becoming disabled made Xavier psychic (as they do with characters like Daredevil and his blindness or Echo and her Deafness), they are purposely creating what they believe to be a powerful dichotomy: a character who is strong in mind and “weak” in body. One of the obvious issues with this portrayal is that it assumes that being disabled is equated with weakness or deficit, projecting a belief that being a wheelchair user means that someone is globally weak.
The figure of “The Genius Cripple” is also one of the reasons why Stephen Hawking has captured the public imagination and even inspired the film, The Theory of Everything (where the role of Hawking is played by an able-bodied actor). Because of the proliferation of cultural images of “The Genius Cripple” trope, Hawking was immediately absorbed into popular culture as a representation of this trope and has appeared (or been portrayed) in shows like The Big Bang Theory, The Simpsons, Star Trek: The Next Generation, Stargate Atlantis, Futurama, and Family Guy. Although the adoption of Hawking into various popular cultural portrayals has meant that greater attention could be drawn to his work, these portrayals are rarely about his actual research and frequently more focused on his status as a representation of the “Genius Cripple” trope. Generally in portrayals of Hawking, narratives tend to focus on his voice and the mobility of his chair while making vague statements about physics, wormholes, or black holes, with little attention going to his research. He is absorbed into popular culture through his ability to represent a trope rather than his actual successes.
One of the key problems with this trope is that it situates the mind and body in direct opposition to each other and assumes that the disabled body is “insufficient” while exalting the mind as something separate from the body. The trope frequently results in statements about a “great mind trapped in a decrepit body,” portraying the disabled body as something that is without inherent worth. It furthers the image of the body of a wheelchair user as “trapped,” a problematic portrayal that frequently occurs in the representation of wheelchair users, who are often described as being “confined to a wheelchair” or “trapped in their wheelchair” when in fact, access to a mobility device provides a degree of freedom that would not otherwise be available to that person.
Other portrayals of this trope can be observed in figures like Oracle from the Batman comics, Alastair Smythe from the Spider-Man comics, Roger Bach from the Alpha Flight comics, Elijah Price from the film, Unbreakable, Dr. Virgil Swann from Smallville, and Davros from Doctor Who.
Derek Newman-Stille is the seven-time Prix Aurora Award winning creator of Speculating Canada. They are completing their PhD at Trent University, researching representations of disability in Canadian speculative fiction. Derek is the editor of the upcoming anthologies: Over the Rainbow: Folk and Fairy Tales From the Margins and We Shall Be Monsters: Frankenstein Two Centuries On. Derek has published in fora like Quill & Quire, The Canadian Fantastic in Focus, Mosaic: A Journal for the Interdisciplinary Study of Literature, Misfit Children: An Inquiry into Childhood Belongings, The Playground of Lost Toys, and Accessing the Future.
Reblogged this on Dis(abled) Embodiment and commented:
Here’s the second of my critiques of Tropes about disability that I have posted on the Spoonie Authors’ Netork. These posts are meant to show the damage that tropes about disability can do to disabled lives.